MARVELOUS MATT
Radio, Photography, Technology, Paranormal.
Wednesday, March 19, 2025
Monday, March 17, 2025
Brushy Bill Roberts: The Man Who Could’ve Outgunned Billy the Kid’s Legend
Brushy Bill Roberts: The Man Who Could’ve Outgunned Billy the Kid’s Legend
Picture this: a moonless night in 1881, a shadowy room in Fort Sumner, New Mexico, and the sharp crack of a gunshot. Sheriff Pat Garrett claims victory—Billy the Kid, the Wild West’s most infamous outlaw, lies dead at 21. The tale’s been told a thousand times: a cocky gunslinger meets his end, buried in a dusty grave, case closed. But what if that’s all a lie? What if Billy didn’t die that night, but instead slipped into the shadows, only to resurface decades later as a weathered old man named Brushy Bill Roberts? Buckle up, because I’m about to take you on a wild ride through history’s backroads to argue that Brushy Bill wasn’t just some dreamer spinning yarns—he was Billy the Kid, and the evidence might just blow your boots off.
Enter Brushy Bill: The Outlaw Who Wouldn’t Quit
The story kicks off in 1948 when a sharp-eyed probate investigator named William V. Morrison gets a tip from Joe Hines, a grizzled survivor of the Lincoln County War. Hines whispers a bombshell: Billy the Kid didn’t die—he’s still kicking. The trail leads Morrison to Hico, Texas, where he meets Oliver “Brushy Bill” Roberts, a wiry old-timer with a twinkle in his eye and a secret bigger than the Rio Grande. After some prodding, Brushy drops the hammer: “I’m Billy the Kid.” He claims he was born in 1859, dodged Garrett’s bullet in ’81, and spent decades ducking the law under aliases before landing in Hico. In 1950, he even tried to snag a pardon from New Mexico’s governor for crimes he swore he’d been promised amnesty for back in 1879. The governor laughed him off, but Brushy’s tale lit a fire that’s still burning. Was this guy a fraud—or the real deal?
The Smoking Guns of Brushy’s Case
Let’s dig into the juicy stuff—why Brushy Bill’s story isn’t just campfire chatter but a legit contender for rewriting history.
Old-Timers Swear He’s the Kid
When Morrison hauled Brushy to New Mexico, he didn’t just get a nod from random folks. Guys like Severo Gallegos, Martile Able, and Jose Montoya—battle-hardened vets of the Lincoln County War who’d ridden with Billy—looked him in the eye and said, “That’s him.” These weren’t strangers; they’d seen Billy’s quick draw and heard his laugh. And Brushy? He spun tales of hideouts and shootouts with details so spot-on, you’d think he’d lived it—because maybe he did.
Scars That Tell a Story
Strip away the years, and Brushy’s body was a roadmap of Billy’s life. He had 26 scars—bullet holes and knife slashes—matching wounds the Kid was known to carry. Shot in the arm in ’79? Check. A double-jointed trick to shrink his hands and slip cuffs? Brushy showed it off like a party trick. Coincidence? I don’t buy it.
Garrett’s Shaky Tale
Here’s where it gets murky. Garrett says he plugged Billy in a dark room at Pete Maxwell’s place, but locals called BS from the jump. His own deputy, John Poe, muttered, “You got the wrong guy.” The body? Buried fast, no parade, no proof—just a quick shovel job before a flood conveniently washed the grave away. Some whisper Garrett killed a patsy—maybe a guy named Billy Barlow—to cash in the bounty. If he’d really bagged the Kid, why’d it take a special law to get his reward?
Brushy Knew Too Much
Brushy didn’t just parrot dime-novel nonsense. He rattled off details—like secret trails, small-time scraps, even chats with Governor Lew Wallace—that nobody dug up until historians got nosy years later. How does a small-town Texan know stuff that wasn’t in books back then? Unless he was there.
Even Garrett’s Crew Had Doubts
Get this: Garrett’s own daughter hinted her dad never killed Billy. And the reward delay? Smells like someone upstairs wasn’t sold on Garrett’s story. If Brushy wasn’t Billy, why’d the cracks in the official yarn keep widening?
Debunking the Doubters
Sure, skeptics have their ammo. A Bible says Brushy was born in 1879—too late to be Billy. But what if that was his cousin’s birth year, a handy alias to dodge the hangman? A 1989 face-match study pegged Brushy’s mug as a mismatch to Billy’s famous tintype, but aging 70 years under the sun could twist any face—and that study’s not gospel. And yeah, some call him a fame-chaser. But Brushy lived quiet, not rich, and chasing that pardon could’ve landed him in a noose. That’s not the move of a con man—it’s the gamble of a guy who believed his truth.
The Kid Who Kept Riding
So, what if Brushy was Billy? He says he bolted that night in ’81, letting Garrett claim a kill. He roamed the frontier, punched cattle, even joined the Rough Riders to fight with Teddy Roosevelt. By the time he hit Hico, he was done running—just an old outlaw hoping for a clean slate. It’s a hell of a yarn: the Kid didn’t die young and reckless; he grew old and crafty.
Why This Wild Tale Matters
If Brushy was Billy, it’s more than a history tweak—it’s a middle finger to the myth. The Wild West wasn’t just shootouts and saloon brawls; it was grit, guile, and second chances. Hico’s all in, with a museum and a statue tipping their hats to Brushy. As of March 17, 2025, we’ve got no DNA to seal the deal—the Kid’s grave’s long gone—but the affidavits, scars, and Garrett’s flimsy tale keep the fire stoked.
So, here’s the kicker: I’m betting Brushy Bill Roberts was Billy the Kid, a legend who outfoxed death and danced through history’s blind spots. What’s your call? Grab a whiskey, stare into the sunset, and decide—because this mystery’s too damn good to let lie.
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
Why the Democratic Party is Failing
Why the Democratic Party is Failing
The Six Million Dollar Man: A Bionic Blast from the Past
The Six Million Dollar Man: A Bionic Blast from the Past
